Log in

24 May 2008 @ 06:41 pm
Weekly Discussion  
 Hello and welcome to our new members!

Here's this week's disussion topic:

If you were in Bella's shoes, would you or would not choose to become a vampire and why?
Current Mood: cheerfulcheerful
Current Music: Wuthering Heights-Hayley Westenra
ashcullen: hot_edwardashcullen on May 25th, 2008 05:27 am (UTC)
Ash Cullen says YES
i cant believe this post hasn't been drowned with comments.
So i might just say that my answer is YES YES YES.
Being in her exact shoes..
there would be no question about it, if i truly loved Edward (or anyone for that matter) i would do anything for him, even if it ment being turned into a vampire, or sacrafising something huge (like in a real life senario...)

I wish i was in er shoes :]
gosh i wish vampires were real

Anyways, i just though i would share that with you..
So that one up on Turning Vamp.
Mrs. 'Oh my God, that Kim is Shameless'atoasterstrudel on May 25th, 2008 02:50 pm (UTC)
Re: atoasterstrudel says maybe, but not for Bella's dumb reasons.
I might, but I'd wait longer and made sure I had better reasons than, "I want to have teh SEX0RZ and not get aaaaall oldddddd becuz u won't luv me anymore!" Plus, her logic is stupid. "I'm ready to be a vampire! Marry you first??! But I'm not READY to be married!"


Bella is a whiny and selfish bitch. I don't really see why Edward would want to be stuck with her for eternity.
Stephanie: parking spotits_stephanie24 on May 26th, 2008 11:46 pm (UTC)
Re: atoasterstrudel says maybe, but not for Bella's dumb reasons.
I agree that she needs better reasoning. What happens if Edward (for some reason) decides he doesn't love her anymore? She gave up her life for one reason that had the potential to change.

I just think she has to really, really, think it through.
Stephanie: dammit Edward! ER is on!its_stephanie24 on May 26th, 2008 11:45 pm (UTC)
Because a mod has to say something :P
I don't think I'd want what she does on one hand. It would kill me to have to give up my family because there's the chance I'd turn them into my next meal.

On the other, if I really loved someone, maybe I would. But I dunno. It's a tough call, I think, and I really think Bella needs to stop being in such a hurry and actually think it through. I mean, once it happens, you can't go back to how it was before. So what happens if Edward (for some reason) does stop loving her? Then what? She amde a choice to end her life for him, and he doesn't want anything to do with her.

I dunno...for me, it's a split decision.